Scout Report: Liam Kemp, FM22 Newgen Competition Winner Yes of course there is a balance to be had here and if you play a player too much too young, then the chances are he will pay a price at the back end of his career. How to develop youth players in FM23 - The Big Tech Question I sign everyone from my youth intake every year, and I know for a fact that some of these players, after a year or maybe two, will all of a sudden have a lot higher PA than on youth intake day. As a second point, but also an addendum, when we refer to top clubs, we dont necessarily mean so in terms of quality or reputation, but in terms of Youth Recruitment. A high PA young player with decent CA is likely to be a decent candidate for staying at the club and playing senior football. There's a quick and easy way to find this out. To reflect the real-life transfer window and other changes in the global football world, the new FM23 patch includes all the latest football transfers, loan deals, staff movements, changes to clubs' transfer budgets and their . What happens if I reduce/increase the Youth Recruitment/Junior Coaching both before preview and after? It should be mentioned at this stage that there is a point after which some if the player info is hard-coded, (the Youth Intake preview), and first of all I'm going to see what is decided then and what is decided at a much later date. Though to me it seems to have an air of self fulfilling prophecy about it. 15. 11. Personalities. Just to confuse things further, normal order is resumed for Youth Recruitment where Adequate again comes before Average. 3. Then you open up that inbox message The stars are relative to the quality of your squad, therefore if Messi is in your team and has 5 stars in his current ability, a youngster with a potential of 3 stars from your youth team means he can be very good if he realizes his potential, world-class even. Optimising Youth Intake I have continued on from the initial Youth Intake preview that had 1x GK and 2x SC's as "A" talents and 1x MC and 1x winger as "B" talents. Highest PA167. Nothing is static. I would love to do even a very basic/limited experiment in this area so I will add it to the list. Intake was observed in October, but it didn't seem based on division. So they are being rated against how good your existing players are now rather than how good they might become in the future. Control Group Average CA. 2nd Nationality. This latest batch of newgens will lead to boundless optimism or incredible disappointment - or something in between. 5 players at 150+ PA. (The laws of probability would suggest that it will be pretty even so something close to 41-41). It is commonly believed that the 1st intake of each save, (for all clubs), is boosted for some reason. Filling out the squads is a no brainer to me. Everyone who doesn't have a "." 2023 Gfinity PLC. I "think" it's too simplistic to say that there is a cut-off like that, but without running an experiment it's hard to quantify, and I would expect the results of any experiment in this area to be open to significant amounts of interpretation, (which is not really the idea). We and our partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. What we do know is that it will be the position, or 1 of the positions in which the player where the player has "Natural" ability. Both of these contribute to the potential for wonderkids and overall good youngsters. 6 players at 150+ PA. FM22 Youth Intakes are one o the best parts of football manager. If you aren't playing competitive football by the time you are 23 you should be asking yourself if you are at the right club (imo). How to Maximise your Youth intakes in FM21 - Football Manager Highest PA 167. For a start there isn't a lot of info there, and I complained for quite a while that the information it did contained had very little, (if any), direct impact on the Youth Intake itself, (although it appears as if those issues have now been resolved and the preview is indeed a snapshot into what will be coming you way later in the season). Likely more game time, but lower standard of everything else. and what seemed strange to me is that the preview with the highest rating of B was still a golden generation, but Preview (with just 1 A rating), wasn't classed as a golden generation. Football Manager 2023 Winter Transfer Update OUT NOW! After a short trial period, you will get to decide which newgens will join your academy, and which will have to look for a new club. Newgens are completely unique players, rather than replicas of retired players. That's by no means an exhaustive list, but it gives us a starting point. They might be kept around to flesh out the U19's or the U23's, but every time I look at them I know they're just a filler and I don't care about their development. 12. There's no statistical information because it's a youtube video and I guess that would be boring, so it's presented as some findings. There are 8 levels of Youth Recruitment, and to see it, you . (I must admit that I had to work out how to sum every 2nd column just for this thread, so every day's a school day as they say). There are things you can do to improve your youth intakes in FM 21. FM22 Journeyman on Twitter: "Youth Intake Preview - December 2025 I'm This all starts from your youth intake email which is separated into four sections; elite, top, good, and decent talents. 7 players at 120+ PA. If you think about France for example, when you think about borders, a Southern based French location should generate more Spanish & Italian Nationalities & 2nd Nationalities, with perhaps more Belgian, Dutch & German being seen further North. That ties in completely with the preview, (which surprises me a little if I'm honest). Plus medical staff to try and ensure my hot prospects are as protected from injury as possible. Also, other factors like facilities in the club, injuries, game time and personality of the players will come into play and influence whether the players realize their potential. Surface Studio vs iMac - Which Should You Pick? Highest CA 100. 1% is a very low chance, but we can improve our chances of creating one by improving our Youth Recruitment. This is the message as it appears in my inbox, but rather than scrolling through the other positions, instead I'm going to click on Dev Centre - Youth Candidates and it makes things easier to view. Improving youth recruitment, youth facilities, and hiring a top head of youth development will undoubtedly lead to fruitful results on youth intake day. Its pretty easy, actually, but well hidden. The next thing I want to so is run this intake 9 more times to see what sort of return we get from 10 previews. Each year, the FM community spends countless hours improving every part of their youth setup to get the best youth intakes, but it can still be a tricky thing to master. PA. Football Manager 2022 - Youth Intake Guide, How Youth Recruitment Affects Youth Intake, Free-transferrable Players (by 2021) Shortlist. TBF there are a lot of really good young players at the club. 8 players at 120+ PA. I had this situation on a few occasions. https://bit.ly/fmscout-youtube FOLLOW FMSCOUTSite https://www.fmscout.comTwitter https://twitter.com/fmscoutFacebook https://www.facebook.com/fmscoutDiscord https://discord.gg/fmscout The performance level achieved when playing. Attributes Range is 1-20; where the 20 means absolute perfect. My theory is some of them are poached away, All of the players in my first youth intake had an D rating or lower . Favoured Personnel. When Are Regens Generated? (Perceived CA. Instead, sign players who are in their prime, and you will see an almost immediate impact. We've already calculated that based on the laws of probability, we should expect to see something like 32 occurrences of this in each section so how many have we got? (I'm expecting that this would impact on the PPA & PCA, but I would like to see it actually happen). The accuracy of player judgement from your staff will also come into play, as they do not get to see the exact value of a players potential or current ability. If a couple move into the U23s as backup, and another one makes the 1st team, you're doing well. So don't worry so much about actual CA and PA, (never mind about PCA and PPA). It's well worth a look. Yeah, if I had a penny for every time I had seen that I would have. lots of pennies. I certainly plan on looking at Nationalities at some point, (but was thinking more along the lines of staff Nationalities & Club Affiliations. It's tempting to stay with so many good youngsters but this is #journeyman #FM21 https://t.co/imx8yjr1Xu" Most of us look at CA in terms of the stars, but if you can't develop the player from his low CA starting point to his potential PA then the high PA doesn't really mean anything. I'm managing in Portugal and playing Youth Only and now have a B Team playing in the 2nd tier in Portugal. You can leave this for last if you're struggling for money. Or is that what is best for the player? We have total CA and PA for each intake at the bottom, (and average CA and PA too). Where to start? 13. PPM's. RealSport101 is supported by its audience. Just for the sake of putting it on record and to confirm that I have checked it, I will also list the things that are fluid and change from save to save. If your squad already has the likes of Mbapp and Haaland, do not expect many 4 or 5 star potential youngsters. Bringing through the next generation of world-class stars is one of Football Manager's most appealing features - youth development is a journey that takes time to get right. I haven't just concentrated on this right back to the detriment of the other right backs who came through intakes before him though. You may know them as regens, which would be an oudated term. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc or its affiliates, Here Are The Best Complete Forwards In FM23, Here Are The Best Deep Lying Forwards In FM23, The Best Way to Use Inverted Wing Backs in Football Manager. What single thing has the biggest impact on the quality of a Youth Intake? As the club we're experimenting with in Spain is actually Melilla, (who are based on the African mainland), I would expect to see more Africans and certainly more Moroccans, but whether that's incorporated into the game I don't know. It contains a comprehensive list of potential people that are fit for the position based on the exact same values we just went over. The thing is though, I still have to use it correctly, (and I wasn't to start off with and I don't think a lot of people do). Highest PA 178. Highest CA 112. Every nation has a hidden attribute called Youth Rating. The 1st thing I have to do is take over a club and I am using my Ceuta save from 1st April 2029, retiring as Manager, adding a new manager and taking over Melila in the Spanish 4th Tier. Media description. The staff at the club. Plus after a little research the only player of Man Utds "class of 92" to go out on loan was Beckham in 1995, where he played all of five games for Preston North End. We know that there are 16 players in a standard intake although this can be increased by the poaching of players from other clubs, (so if you poached 1 player from another Youth Team/Academy then you would get an intake of 17 players, but at this stage I can't remember/confirm what happens if you are the club who has a player poached. On the other hand, if you want to play 2 up front or 3 in the middle then this might be right up your street. at the end of a players name if I have decided they don't have a future at the club as a 1st Team player. I will then post the info on 10 different Intakes all run with how the facilities are in the game as is, and then I will change things using the in game editor, go back and run the intake again, (10 more times) and see what gets thrown up. Free bonuses: Early beta access \u0026 a special badge for site members. Sports Interactive 2016 PPA. All attributes, (with the exception of GK rating at this stage), (and that means I have to check the outfield rating for the GK). I love this and will follow the results here with much interest! Director of Football. In the same vein, your head of youth development might get the potential of your youth intake wrong. Guess the question is does each player account for a single number on the graphic. 4. Highest PA 178. More than them staying in my U23 team where they use training facilities and staff I have control over the quality of. Whether he's right or wrong doesn't matter. 6. Highest PA 167. In terms of player development is there an experiment that we could run that would compare development of players who stayed in the U19's, players who were given a couple/few outings in the 1st Team, and the same player going out on loan at a lower level? Or does it mean the position that the HoYD would prefer to play the player in? The video I looked at concerned the impact of (Pro), (Amb), (Det) and Morale on player growth with is pretty relevant to this thread and I really liked it. This potential group of players is distributed throughout all clubs in the country, with every club getting a chance to produce any combination of the aforementioned players. If he has a "Professional" personality, then there's a chance new players will have that personality as well. 5. . These will increase the prospect of a 'golden generation' or two for your club, but you won't get quality players every. Youth Intake Challenge - Football Manager Challenges - FM23 - Football (26.26 compared to 26.24). Injury susceptibility. My plan is to properly dissect this to death, but I'm not going to be doing it all in 1 go. One of the clubs had intake Mid-November. Total intake is result of two division's intake. CA. FM Mythbusting: Youth Intakes - Fuller FM This is not because you are getting better players than teams in the higher divisions, but rather because your current first team players are relatively poor and therefore more youngsters coming through the youth system have the potential to be better than them. Interested in poaching the best Heads of Youth Development the game has to offer? FM Tips \u0026 tricks, gameplay, wonderkids, tactic replications \u0026 tests, how-to tutorials, experiments \u0026 more. You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. So I will admit to being particularly curious as to what the results would show here. I can't begin to tell you how beneficial I have found the B Team. It was largely due to their combined talent, that Dynamo had its period of greatest domestic and international success. I've got something in there already that touched on this. Thanks. Training performances, (driven my multiple things). This group were so good that they were all asked to train with the senior squad early on and all impressed. Highest PA 179. What can change? For example, for leagues we had set as View Only, only the top clubs within them had a consistent, yearly, Youth Intake. 8. We're looking at 16 players, (16 numbers), we're looking at both CA and PA, (32 numbers), and we're looking at 10 different intakes in each experiment, (320 numbers), so by the laws of probability you would expect somewhere in the region of 32 CA's or PA's to end in a 1 digit, 32 CA's or PA's to end in a 2, 32 CA's or PA's to end in a 3 etc etc etc etc. Rather than using the words "more important", I think there is more control that you can exert over the development of a younger player, (such as PPM's and additional focus), but if a player is ready for Senior football at 17, (and that involves a loan elsewhere), then I think there certainly isn't a hard and fast rule to say that he will develop better playing for the U19's at home rather than the 1st Team at a lower level. The Best Football Manager 2022 Youth Academies - Scouted Football I think it would help to see the total PA & CA of the intakes as well as the basic number of players. What influences the Nationality & Secondary Nationality of players? After all, a L20 Training Facility is a flippin enormous investment. The facilities at the club. You know i'm (or was) playing with Africanos Bragana with only Cape Verde intakes. On the other hand, if you are a managing team in the lower leagues, the probability of having the golden generation description during a youth intake is higher than when you are managing in the Premier League or another top league in Europe.